Hotcha! Chicago, now in its 19th year on Broadway, is celebrating another momentous milestone this weekend—the Tony-winning revival is surpassing Cats to become the second longest-running show in Broadway history! A whole slew of Chicago alums are returning to celebrate on November 23, including original stars Ann Reinking, Bebe Neuwirth, James Naughton and Joel Grey, as well as John O’Hurley, Marilu Henner and Michelle Williams. Tons of celebrities have done stints in Chicago over the years, but isn’t it time a real-life tabloid star stepped into the cellblock? So meta! Cast your vote for your favorite tabloid sensation below.